I have received emails today from several followers indicating that their short position in the Macy’s August 16 $23 put options have been called away. These are one leg of the Macys (M) August 2019 $23-$25 in-the-money vertical BEAR PUT spread which I recommended on August 6.
I am responding with an EMERGENCY ALERT because some brokers, notably Charles Schwab, are advising their customers exactly the wrong thing to do. They are telling their customers to take out a huge leveraged margin positions to cover a long position in Macy’s shares at $23 a share. YOU SHOULD NOT FOLLOW THIS ADVICE!
Instead, you should simply tell your broker to exercise you long Macy’s August 16 $25 put options to cover your short Macy’s August $23 put options and take home the maximum potential profit one day before expiration.
Your long Macy’s August 16 $25 put options more than covers any losses in the short Macy’s August $23 put options plus a handsome profit.
Remember, when you are short a put option and it get exercised against you or called away, you automatically own the shares. In the case of the Macy’s August 16 $23 put options, you now own 100 shares for each option contract you were short. Short 57 contracts means you are now long 5,700 shares, worth $91,200 shares in a plunging market.
Most of you have short option positions, although you may not realize it. For when you buy an in-the-money put option spread, it contains two elements: a long put and a short put. The short put can get assigned, or called away at any time.
You have to be careful here because the inexperienced can blow their newfound windfall if they take the wrong action, so here’s how to handle it.
Puts are a right to sell shares at a fixed price before a fixed date, and one option contract is exercisable into 100 shares.
Sounds like a good trade to me.
Weird stuff like this happens in the run-up to options expirations.
Ordinary shares may not be available in the market, or maybe a limit order didn’t get done by the stock market close.
There are thousands of algorithms out there which may arrive at some twisted logic that the puts need to be exercised.
Many require a rebalancing of hedges at the close every day which can be achieved through option exercises.
And yes, puts even get exercised by accident. There are still a few humans left in this market to blow it.
And here’s another possible outcome in this process.
Your broker will call you to notify you of an option called away, and then give you the wrong advice on what to do about it.
This generates tons of commissions for the broker but is a terrible thing for the trader to do from a risk point of view, such as generating a loss by the time everything is closed and netted out.
Avarice could have been an explanation here but I think stupidity and poor training and low wages are much more likely.
Brokers have so many ways to steal money legally that they don’t need to resort to the illegal kind.
This exercise process is now fully automated at most brokers but it never hurts to follow up with a phone call if you get an exercise notice. Mistakes do happen.
Some may also send you a link to a video of what to do about all this.
If any of you are the slightest bit worried or confused by all of this, come out of your position RIGHT NOW at a small profit! You should never be worried or confused about any position tying up YOUR money.
Professionals do these things all day long and exercises become second nature, just another cost of doing business.
If you do this long enough, eventually you get hit. I bet you don’t.
